Holiday & Festival Volume Failures: When “Profit” Overrides Protocol

Entertainment districts thrive on high-volume events. St. Patrick’s Day, New Year’s Eve, and city-wide music festivals are often the most profitable nights of the year. However, they are also the nights where the standard of care is most frequently abandoned. In litigation, venues often claim that the chaos of a festival night was “unforeseeable” or […]

The “Dump and Run”: Liability in Patron Ejections & Security Handoffs

In a standalone bar, ejecting an aggressive patron solves the immediate problem. But in a dense entertainment district, an ejection often just moves the problem 50 feet down the sidewalk, creating a new liability exposure for the venue that pushed him out. Defense counsel often argues that once a patron leaves the premises, the duty […]

When Club Bylaws Prove Negligence

In standard dram shop cases, we measure a venue’s actions against state liquor laws. In private club litigation, there is a second, often more damaging yardstick: the club’s own bylaws. Private clubs pride themselves on high standards of conduct, which are codified in extensive rulebooks, house rules, and membership agreements. When a club fails to […]

The “VIP Member” Liability Trap

In a standard commercial bar, a bartender has the authority—and the legal mandate—to cut off an intoxicated patron. If a customer becomes aggressive, security removes them. In a private club, that dynamic is often inverted. The intoxicated patron is not just a customer; they are a “member,” an owner, and potentially the bartender’s boss. This […]

Defeating the “Social Host” Defense

Private clubs—whether city clubs, yacht clubs, or fraternal orders—often operate under a dangerous misconception: they believe they are immune from Dram Shop liability because they are “private” organizations rather than commercial bars. In litigation, defense counsel frequently leverages the “Social Host” defense, arguing that the club is merely a gathering of friends and not a […]

Underage Alcohol Compliance System Review

Importance of Compliance Systems in Service to Minors Cases Service to minors cases often turn on whether a venue maintained functional compliance systems rather than whether a single employee made an error. Alcohol service environments are complex, fast moving, and subject to regulatory expectations that require consistent enforcement. Expert witness analysis focuses on how compliance […]